BBC pundit says £42m player Man City let go last year is simply ‘not good enough’ to play for them

Redaction Simon Brett with Srinivas Sadhanand
Published on 2024-04-22 08:30:00

BBC pundit Garth Crooks believes that Manchester City made a mistake by selling players like Ilkay Gundogan and Riyad Mahrez last summer. These players were considered key components of the team, with their absence being felt in games where City struggled, especially against top teams. Despite efforts from Guardiola and others to convince them to stay, the players chose to explore new challenges, leading to debates about whether the decision to sell them was right or wrong.

Garth Crooks also expressed doubt about the level of young player Cole Palmer, suggesting that he is not yet good enough to play for Manchester City. However, Palmer’s versatility as both a winger and attacking midfielder makes this assessment questionable, especially since City have not fully established a primary right-winger. His potential to develop and contribute to the team in different roles could have been valuable if he had remained at the club, challenging Crooks’ opinion about his current abilities.

While City have faced criticism for selling key players like Gundogan and Mahrez, the debate over the abilities of young talents like Cole Palmer continues. The team’s struggles at times this season have raised questions about the impact of these player sales on their overall performance, with many wondering if retaining certain players could have made a difference. In the end, the decisions made by City regarding player sales have sparked discussions among fans and pundits about the team’s current squad composition and future prospects.

Read Full article on Manchester City News