Manchester City supporters have delivered a surprisingly divided reaction to reports that Tijjani Reijnders could leave the club for Al Qadsiah.
According to the report used as the basis for the story, Al Qadsiah are in advanced negotiations with Manchester City over a deal for the midfielder. The clubs have reportedly reached an agreement around a €60 million fee, although Reijnders still has to give the green light before the transfer can be completed.
The reaction from City supporters on X, however, suggests there is little consensus about what should happen next.
Some fans believe Manchester City should accept the offer immediately. Others want a higher fee. A smaller group are firmly against the transfer and insist that Reijnders should not be sold at all.
One supporter summed up the more enthusiastic side of the reaction with a simple message: “Good news.”
Another went much further, writing: “sell and upgrade lol.”
But perhaps the most revealing comment came from a fan who declared: “He’s not for sale.”
The contrasting opinions show just how complicated the Reijnders situation has become.
Manchester City fans split over Reijnders sale
The reported €60m valuation immediately became one of the main talking points among supporters.
One City fan argued that Manchester City should demand more, writing: “It should be €70-80 mill.”
That comment reflects a belief among some supporters that Reijnders’ value should be higher than the reported figure.
Manchester City invested heavily to bring the midfielder to the club, and his performances have helped establish him as an important part of the squad.
Therefore, some fans appear unwilling to see him leave for what they consider a relatively modest fee.
At the same time, other supporters see the potential sale differently.
One fan simply wrote “Good news”, while another posted “sell and upgrade lol.”
Those reactions suggest that some City supporters believe an exit could create an opportunity to strengthen the squad.
That is particularly relevant as the club begins a new era under Enzo Maresca.
‘Sell and get Enzo ASAP’ – fans already thinking about replacements
One of the most eye-catching reactions came from a supporter who wrote: “sell and get enzo asap.”
The comment appears to refer to another midfielder rather than Manchester City’s new head coach, and it highlights the way transfer discussions quickly turn into debates about possible replacements.
For some supporters, selling Reijnders would only make sense if Manchester City could reinvest the money in another high-quality midfielder.
That is the central question surrounding the potential transfer.
A €60m departure would provide Manchester City with significant funds. However, replacing a first-team midfielder is not necessarily straightforward.
If Maresca sees Reijnders as an important part of his midfield plans, losing him could create an unwanted gap.
On the other hand, if the manager believes another player would fit his tactical approach better, the club could decide that accepting a substantial offer makes sense.
Some fans want Reijnders to stay
Not every Manchester City supporter welcomed the reported negotiations.
One fan simply responded: “PLEASE”, seemingly pleading for the midfielder to remain at the club.
Another was even more direct: “He’s not for sale.”
That comment attracted significant engagement, showing that there is a sizeable section of the fanbase that does not want to see Reijnders leave.
The reaction is understandable.
Reijnders offers qualities that are difficult to replace. His ability to carry the ball from midfield, contribute offensively and operate between the lines makes him a useful player in different tactical situations.
For a new manager, having a midfielder with that versatility can be extremely valuable.
Maresca is therefore facing an important decision.
The Italian coach inherited a talented squad, but he will also want to establish his own identity. Players who fit his preferred style will be particularly important.
If Reijnders is considered part of those plans, City will have little reason to entertain a sale.
‘Awful midfielder’ – not every fan is convinced
Interestingly, the reaction was not universally positive towards Reijnders.
One supporter described him bluntly as an “Awful midfielder.”
That comment received substantial engagement, demonstrating that there are City fans who believe selling the Dutch international would not be a major loss.
It is a reminder that social media reactions are rarely unanimous.
A player can be highly rated by one section of supporters while another group questions his consistency or suitability.
Reijnders’ potential departure therefore raises a wider debate about his actual importance to Manchester City.
Is he a player the club should build around?
Or is he someone whose value could be maximised by selling at the right moment?
The answer depends heavily on how Maresca evaluates him.
‘Probably for the best for both’
Another supporter offered a more measured assessment, writing: “Probably for the best for both.”
That view sits somewhere between the two extremes.
Rather than arguing that Reijnders is either indispensable or expendable, the comment suggests that a separation could benefit both parties.
For the player, a move to Al Qadsiah could potentially offer a new challenge and a different role.
For Manchester City, the transfer could generate a significant fee that could be reinvested into the squad.
However, the reported €60m agreement does not mean the transfer is guaranteed.
The midfielder still needs to approve the move.
That is a crucial detail.
Manchester City and Al Qadsiah may have reached an understanding over the fee, but Reijnders ultimately has a say in his future.
‘Wrong decision’ shows the concern among some supporters
Another fan responded: “Wrong decision but what do I know.”
The comment captures the uncertainty surrounding the potential sale.
Supporters understand that transfers are complicated. They also know that managers and sporting directors have access to information that fans do not.
Still, losing an established midfielder can be risky.
Manchester City are entering a new managerial era, and stability could be important.
Maresca will need time to implement his ideas. Removing an important player from the midfield could make that process more difficult.
Equally, keeping a player who does not fit the manager’s plans would create its own problems.
The decision therefore needs to be based on football rather than simply the size of the transfer fee.
‘No way Titanic accepts this’
One particularly cryptic reaction read: “No way Titanic accepts this.”
Whatever the exact intended reference, the comment reflects the disbelief among some supporters that the proposed deal could actually go through.
For those fans, the reported transfer does not feel inevitable.
That is important because the situation remains dependent on Reijnders’ decision.
Until the midfielder agrees personal terms and gives his approval, Manchester City supporters can continue to debate whether the transfer makes sense.
What would Reijnders’ departure mean for Maresca?
The biggest question is what the potential transfer means for Enzo Maresca.
The new Manchester City head coach is beginning his first season after succeeding Pep Guardiola in June 2026.
That makes squad decisions particularly important.
Maresca needs players who can execute his tactical instructions. Midfield is likely to be one of the most important areas of his team.
Reijnders’ technical ability and movement could make him useful in a system that demands midfielders capable of progressing the ball and contributing in attacking areas.
Selling him could therefore be viewed as a major tactical decision.
However, if Maresca has identified another midfielder as a better fit, the situation could change quickly.
That explains why some fans are comfortable with the idea of a sale while others are desperate for City to reject it.
The €60m question
Ultimately, money could determine how Manchester City approach the situation.
One fan believes the club should demand €70m-€80m, while others appear happy to accept the reported €60m.
The difference of €10m-€20m could become important during negotiations.
Manchester City have traditionally been aggressive when it comes to protecting the value of their players. If the club believes Reijnders is worth more, it could push Al Qadsiah for an improved offer.
But if City are comfortable with the valuation, negotiations could move rapidly once the player makes his decision.
Manchester City fans have made their feelings clear
The reaction to the Tijjani Reijnders transfer reports is anything but straightforward.
Some supporters want him gone.
Others want Manchester City to keep him.
Some believe €60m is enough.
Others want €70m-€80m.
And several fans are already discussing possible replacements.
The strongest messages ranged from “He’s not for sale” to “sell and upgrade lol”, showing just how divided the fanbase has become.
Ultimately, the decision will not belong to supporters.
Manchester City must decide whether Reijnders remains part of Maresca’s plans, while the midfielder himself still has to approve any move to Al Qadsiah.
For now, the reported €60m agreement is only one step in the process.
And judging by the reaction from City fans, the next step could generate an even bigger debate.
