Manchester City supporters have been debating who deserves to win the club’s October Player of the Month award after Erling Haaland, Elliot Anderson and Phil Foden were named on the shortlist.
The three players enjoyed impressive spells during October, giving supporters an interesting decision ahead of the public vote.
However, the early reaction from Manchester City fans suggests that Elliot Anderson has attracted considerable support, with several supporters openly calling for the midfielder to receive the award.
Others believe Haaland should be recognised for another outstanding month in front of goal, while Foden’s impressive performances have also earned him recognition.
A post shared by City Xtra on X attracted plenty of responses, with supporters quickly making their preferences known.
And although there is no unanimous agreement, the conversation has highlighted just how highly Anderson is already regarded by sections of the City fanbase.
Elliot Anderson emerges as a popular choice among Man City supporters
Anderson appears to be one of the leading favourites among supporters responding to the nominations.
The midfielder has made an impressive start to life at Manchester City, and his performances during October have clearly caught the attention of the fanbase.
Several supporters were particularly direct when expressing their preference.
One fan, Perfect🩵, wrote:
“Elliot Anderson should win.”
Another supporter, DAVID, made his feelings equally clear:
“Just give Anderson.”
The Priest also backed the midfielder, writing:
“Anderson deserve it.”
Meanwhile, MORRIS expressed his support with a simple but enthusiastic endorsement:
“Anderson 👍”
Alfa Full Option also joined the growing number of supporters backing the England international, posting:
“Give this to Elliot Anderson.”
These reactions suggest that Anderson has made a strong impression since arriving at the Etihad Stadium.
His influence in midfield has been particularly noticeable, with his energy, ability to carry possession and contribution to City’s overall play making him an important figure.
The club’s official nomination announcement also highlighted his performance in the 3-0 victory away to Liverpool at the beginning of October.
Anderson continued his impressive form throughout the month and eventually celebrated his first Manchester City goal during the emphatic 5-1 victory over AEK Athens.
Those performances help explain why so many supporters believe he deserves recognition.
For a midfielder still establishing himself at a new club, receiving such strong backing from the fanbase is an encouraging sign.
‘Haaland’ – Some fans believe the Norwegian striker deserves the award
Although Anderson received plenty of support, he was not the only player attracting votes from Manchester City supporters.
Erling Haaland also had his supporters, with several fans believing that his goalscoring contribution during October should make him the favourite.
One supporter, addielessie, kept the response short and simple:
“Haaland”
Another fan, Emah_mcfc, offered a more balanced assessment of the three nominees while ultimately favouring the Norwegian.
The supporter wrote:
“Haaland, but Phil and Anderson has been phenomenal.”
That reaction captures the difficulty of choosing a winner from this particular shortlist.
Haaland’s goalscoring numbers during October were once again outstanding.
According to Manchester City’s official announcement, the striker scored in Premier League victories over Liverpool and Aston Villa, while also registering twice against Ipswich.
His Champions League performances were equally impressive.
The Norwegian scored twice against Paris Saint-Germain, taking his October total to six goals in five matches.
Those numbers provide a strong argument for his inclusion and demonstrate why he remains one of the most influential players in Maresca’s Manchester City side.
For supporters who prioritise decisive contributions in front of goal, Haaland’s achievements make a convincing case.
Anderson may have attracted plenty of enthusiasm, but the Norwegian’s consistency in front of goal means the competition is far from straightforward.
Phil Foden also receives recognition after impressive October performances
While much of the discussion has centred on Anderson and Haaland, Phil Foden should not be overlooked.
The England international also enjoyed an excellent October, producing some memorable attacking performances after returning from suspension.
Foden’s month started with a goal in Manchester City’s 3-2 victory over Ipswich.
He then delivered an outstanding performance against AEK Athens, scoring a hat-trick and providing an assist for Rayan Cherki.
It was a particularly impressive contribution and further demonstrated his ability to influence matches in the final third.
Emah_mcfc specifically recognised Foden’s contribution, describing both him and Anderson as phenomenal despite favouring Haaland for the award.
That is an important point because Foden’s nomination is not simply a reward for his reputation.
His performances during the month provided a genuine argument for recognition.
The attacking midfielder has consistently shown that he can change games through his movement, creativity and ability to find the net.
Under head coach Enzo Maresca, maintaining that level of attacking influence will be important as City continue their campaign.
Foden’s nomination also means that supporters have three players with very different strengths to consider.
Haaland offers exceptional goalscoring output, Anderson brings energy and midfield quality, while Foden provides creativity and attacking threat.
Man City supporters make their choices clear
The comments under the City Xtra post reveal an interesting difference in opinion.
Anderson received several direct endorsements, with supporters such as Perfect🩵, DAVID, The Priest and Alfa Full Option all backing him.
Haaland also attracted support, particularly from fans who believe his goals should carry significant weight in the decision.
Meanwhile, Foden received recognition from supporters who acknowledged the quality of his October performances.
Connor Rigby also congratulated all three nominees, writing:
“Massive Congratulations To Erling Haaland, Elliot Anderson, And Phil Foden Who Have Been Nominated For #ManCity’s October Player OF The Month Award. 🩵🩵🩵🩵🩵🩵”
That reaction reflects another important aspect of the discussion.
Regardless of who eventually wins, all three players have earned recognition for their contributions.
The nomination itself is an achievement, especially considering that Manchester City recorded four victories during October and had several players in contention.
The club ultimately selected Anderson, Haaland and Foden for the public vote.
Who deserves Manchester City’s October Player of the Month award?
There are strong arguments for all three nominees, but the decision ultimately depends on what supporters value most.
If goalscoring output is the main consideration, Haaland has an excellent case.
Six goals in five October matches is an impressive achievement, particularly given the importance of his contributions in both domestic and European competitions.
Foden also has a compelling argument.
His hat-trick against AEK Athens, combined with his goal against Ipswich and assist for Cherki, made him one of City’s standout attacking performers.
However, Anderson’s nomination is particularly encouraging because of the consistency and influence he has brought to midfield.
His performance against Liverpool was a major highlight, while his first City goal against AEK Athens provided another memorable moment.
The supporters backing Anderson clearly believe his overall contribution deserves greater recognition.
And judging by the early responses, there is considerable enthusiasm behind that argument.
The final result will depend on the public vote rather than the comments under a single social media post.
Manchester City have confirmed that voting closes at 14:00 UK time on Friday, 6 November.
Verdict: Anderson has strong fan backing, but Haaland and Foden remain serious contenders
The reaction to Manchester City’s October Player of the Month nominations shows that supporters have plenty to debate.
Anderson has attracted particularly vocal backing, with several fans insisting that he should receive the award after an impressive start to life at the Etihad Stadium.
Haaland, meanwhile, has the goalscoring numbers to make an equally convincing case.
Foden’s outstanding contribution against AEK Athens also means he cannot be discounted.
For Maresca, having three players producing such influential performances is an encouraging situation.
For supporters, however, the question is much simpler: who deserves the recognition?
At this stage, Anderson appears to have generated plenty of excitement among those responding to the City Xtra post.
But with Haaland’s goals and Foden’s attacking brilliance also in the conversation, the October award promises to be an interesting contest.
One thing is certain: Manchester City have had no shortage of standout performers, and all three nominees have given supporters a reason to celebrate.
