Manchester City supporters have delivered a surprisingly mixed reaction to the club’s reported pursuit of Allan Elias, with some fans demanding that the deal be completed immediately while others are questioning whether the Brazilian forward is really what the team needs.
City are understood to be closing in on an agreement with Palmeiras for Elias, with a fixed transfer fee of around €40 million being discussed. The development has generated plenty of discussion among supporters, particularly because many believe Manchester City still need reinforcements in other areas of the squad.
The reaction to the latest Allan Elias transfer update was therefore far from unanimous.
Some supporters simply want the club to stop negotiating and complete the deal. Others are already comparing the potential signing to previous Brazilian arrivals who struggled to make the expected impact.
With Enzo Maresca now in charge at Manchester City after succeeding Pep Guardiola in June 2026, the new manager will ultimately have to decide how Elias fits into his plans.
“Get it done quickly” — some fans want no more delays
One of the clearest themes among supporters was impatience.
The word “close” appears to have become particularly frustrating for some City fans. Supporter Cityforever summed up that feeling by reacting to the transfer update with a demand for the club to finish the job.
“Get it done,” was essentially the message.
Another supporter, CityDoctrine, was even more direct: “Get it done. Quickly.”
That reaction reflects a wider feeling around Manchester City’s transfer activity. Supporters do not simply want rumours anymore. They want completed deals.
When a player is reportedly close to joining, many fans expect the final steps to happen quickly. Any further delays can create anxiety, especially when other clubs are also active in the transfer market.
The Allan Elias transfer has therefore become another test of patience for the City faithful.
Not everyone is convinced by Allan Elias
However, the reaction was not overwhelmingly positive.
Some Manchester City supporters questioned why the club is pursuing another attacking player when they believe midfield remains a more urgent area.
One fan bluntly wrote: “Another mid.”
Another supporter made the argument even clearer, saying: “We need a midfielder more than these.”
That criticism is important because it highlights the difference between signing a talented player and addressing the most obvious weakness in the squad.
City supporters are not necessarily against Elias. Instead, some want the club to prioritise the positions they believe require immediate attention.
That distinction matters.
A €40 million investment in a young attacker can be viewed as sensible squad planning. But if supporters believe the midfield needs strengthening first, excitement over a new forward can quickly turn into frustration.
“He better prove us all wrong”
Perhaps the most interesting reaction came from fans who were not completely sold on the move but were willing to give Elias an opportunity.
One supporter wrote: “He better prove us all wrong.”
That perfectly captures the mood among some sections of the fanbase.
They may not be excited by the reported fee or convinced that Elias is the priority signing, but they will support the player if he arrives and performs.
Football supporters can change their opinions very quickly.
A player who initially receives criticism can become a fan favourite after a few important performances. Conversely, a highly anticipated signing can quickly find himself under pressure if he struggles.
For Elias, the challenge would be to make an immediate impression.
If Manchester City complete the deal, the 20-year-old would arrive with significant expectations despite his age. The transfer fee would naturally add pressure, but performances would ultimately determine how supporters judge him.
The Savio comparison is already appearing
One of the more sceptical reactions compared the potential arrival to Savinho.
A supporter simply wrote: “Savio 2.0 incoming.”
The comparison shows how some fans are thinking about Manchester City’s recent recruitment from South America.
Brazilian players arriving at a club of City’s size often come with huge expectations. The transition from South American football to the Premier League can be difficult, particularly when players are expected to compete immediately for places at one of Europe’s strongest clubs.
That does not mean Elias will follow the same path as Savinho.
Every player is different, and his development will depend on coaching, adaptation, opportunities and the role Maresca gives him.
Still, the comparison demonstrates why some supporters are approaching the transfer with caution.
“Good news” — others are excited
Despite the scepticism, there was also plenty of positivity.
One supporter described the news simply as “Good news”, while another urged City forward with “cmonnn cityy”.
That enthusiasm should not be overlooked.
There are clearly supporters who believe Elias could become an exciting addition to Maresca’s squad. The fact that Manchester City are reportedly willing to invest around €40 million suggests the club sees significant potential in the player.
For those supporters, the transfer represents another investment in the future.
Manchester City have built much of their recent success around combining established stars with younger players who can develop into important first-team figures. Elias could potentially become another part of that strategy.
Some fans are already frustrated by the transfer updates
Interestingly, the frustration was not only directed at the player.
Some supporters appeared exhausted by the repeated transfer updates themselves.
One fan wrote: “We are tired of this update.”
Another posted: “…..sigh”, while another reacted with a simple “WHY”.
This suggests that supporters are increasingly looking for certainty rather than speculation.
Transfer stories can dominate social media for weeks. Fans follow every update, every reported negotiation and every development. But when a deal remains “close” without being completed, excitement can turn into fatigue.
The Allan Elias situation appears to have reached that stage for some supporters.
They want to see the announcement rather than another update about negotiations.
Questions over the club’s priorities
The biggest issue raised by the reaction is not necessarily Elias himself.
It is Manchester City’s transfer strategy.
Several supporters questioned whether the club should be spending €40 million on another attacking option when midfield reinforcements remain a major concern.
One fan directly addressed the club’s recruitment leadership, demanding that midfielders be signed instead.
That frustration reflects the pressure now facing the new Manchester City hierarchy.
Maresca inherited a squad that is still expected to compete for major honours. The transition from Guardiola to a new manager means recruitment decisions will be closely examined.
Every signing will be judged not only on the player’s individual ability but also on whether the transfer solves an obvious squad problem.
Elias therefore faces an unusual situation.
He could arrive as a talented young player and still be questioned before playing a single minute because of the positions supporters believe City should strengthen.
The pressure will be on Maresca too
The Allan Elias transfer could also tell us something about Maresca’s vision for Manchester City.
The Italian manager has inherited a squad undergoing change. If Elias arrives, supporters will want to know exactly how he fits into the new system.
Will he be used immediately?
Will he be developed gradually?
Could he compete for a starting position?
Those questions will become more important if Manchester City complete the transfer.
Maresca’s ability to develop young players could ultimately be crucial. If Elias shows his quality under the new manager, the current scepticism could disappear very quickly.
Manchester City fans are demanding more than just a signing
Ultimately, the reaction to the Allan Elias transfer shows a fanbase that wants action.
Some supporters are excited.
Some are sceptical.
Others simply want the club to finish the deal and move on to the next priority.
The strongest message from the reactions is that Manchester City supporters do not want endless transfer updates. They want completed business and, importantly, the right players for the right positions.
The €40 million reported fee makes Elias an intriguing investment, but the pressure will increase if the club fails to address midfield concerns.
For now, the Allan Elias transfer remains a developing story. If Manchester City complete the deal, the Brazilian youngster will have the perfect opportunity to silence the doubters.
And judging by the reaction from supporters, there will be plenty of doubters waiting to be proven wrong.
